Skip to content
The Bonsai Art

Soils · 12 materials

Soil types and how they differ

Good bonsai soil balances three things: it holds water, lets air through and does not break down over the years. No material does all three, which is why they are mixed.

Comparison of soil materials
TypeHolds waterAerationDurabilitypHRecommendation
Akadama4/53/52/5 6–6,8 Base of the mix
Kanuma4/53/52/5 4,5–5,5 Base of the mix
Kiryu2/54/55/5 5,5–6,5 Supplement
Pumice3/55/55/5 Neutral Base of the mix
Lava rock (scoria)2/55/55/5 Neutral Base of the mix
Zeolite3/54/55/5 Neutral Supplement
Quartz grit and coarse sand1/54/55/5 Neutral Supplement
Expanded clay pebbles1/55/55/5 Neutral Avoid in bonsai
Perlite2/54/52/5 Neutral Avoid in bonsai
Composted pine bark3/53/52/5 Acidic Supplement
Coir5/52/52/5 Slightly acidic Avoid in bonsai
Peat and potting compost5/51/51/5 Acidic Avoid in bonsai

Scale of 1 to 5 dots. Indicative values: they vary with particle size and the quality of each brand.

Japanese minerals

  • Akadama granules in a training pot with a pine
    Photo: Globalist1789 / Wikimedia Commons

    Base of the mix赤玉土

    Akadama

    Fired volcanic clay from the Kantō region of Japan.

    Holds water
    4/5
    Aeration
    3/5
    Durability
    2/5
    pH
    6–6,8

    It holds water and nutrients well and changes colour as it dries, so it tells you when to water. Over the years and through frosts it breaks down into dust, which is why trees are repotted every few years. Hard-grade akadama lasts much longer.

    Use for: Base of almost every mix, especially deciduous and tropical trees.

  • Base of the mix鹿沼土

    Kanuma

    Weathered volcanic pumice from Kanuma (Tochigi, Japan).

    Holds water
    4/5
    Aeration
    3/5
    Durability
    2/5
    pH
    4,5–5,5

    Light, pale yellow and soft. Its acidic pH is what sets it apart: it keeps lime-hating species healthy. It breaks down a little faster than akadama.

    Use for: Satsuki azaleas and other acid-loving species, on its own or with some pumice.

  • Supplement桐生砂

    Kiryu

    Iron-rich volcanic sand from Kiryū (Gunma, Japan).

    Holds water
    2/5
    Aeration
    4/5
    Durability
    5/5
    pH
    5,5–6,5

    Hard, heavy, angular grains that do not break down. It drains very fast and makes the tree more stable in the pot. Harder to find and more expensive than lava.

    Use for: Pines and junipers, mixed with akadama.

Volcanic and other minerals

  • Pieces of light, porous pumice
    Photo: Hausmaus / Wikimedia Commons

    Base of the mix

    Pumice

    Foamy volcanic rock full of pores.

    Holds water
    3/5
    Aeration
    5/5
    Durability
    5/5
    pH
    Neutral

    Light and very porous: it holds water inside its pores but leaves plenty of air between particles. It never breaks down. Fine roots grip its rough surface well. It is so light it floats on the first watering.

    Use for: Any species. It lightens mixes and improves drainage.

  • Red volcanic scoria granules next to a geologist’s hammer
    Photo: Wilson44691 / Wikimedia Commons

    Base of the mix

    Lava rock (scoria)

    Crushed volcanic scoria, red or black.

    Holds water
    2/5
    Aeration
    5/5
    Durability
    5/5
    pH
    Neutral

    Heavier and less porous than pumice. It adds structure and very fast drainage, and its weight steadies tall trees. The grains are rough: take care with fine roots.

    Use for: Conifers, olives and species that like to dry out between waterings.

  • Supplement

    Zeolite

    A volcanic aluminosilicate mineral.

    Holds water
    3/5
    Aeration
    4/5
    Durability
    5/5
    pH
    Neutral

    It does not break down and holds nutrients on its surface, releasing them gradually. Its colour does not change as it dries, so mix it with akadama to see when to water.

    Use for: A long-lasting supplement, replacing part of the akadama.

  • Crushed 10 mm gravel in a hand
    Photo: a22375 / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

    Supplement

    Quartz grit and coarse sand

    Washed quartz grit or river sand, 2 to 5 mm.

    Holds water
    1/5
    Aeration
    4/5
    Durability
    5/5
    pH
    Neutral

    Cheap and durable, but heavy and with almost no water retention. Never beach sand (it contains salt) or fine builder’s sand, which clogs the pot.

    Use for: A small share of mixes for olive, wild olive and drought-tolerant species.

  • Orange expanded clay pebbles
    Photo: Lucis / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 3.0

    Avoid in bonsai

    Expanded clay pebbles

    Fired clay balls, hollow inside.

    Holds water
    1/5
    Aeration
    5/5
    Durability
    5/5
    pH
    Neutral

    Their smooth, round surface holds no water and roots cannot grip it. They also float and shift when watered. Often sold as “bonsai soil”, but they are not.

    Use for: Only as a drainage layer in large growing pots.

  • A heap of white horticultural perlite
    Photo: Ragesoss / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 3.0

    Avoid in bonsai

    Perlite

    Volcanic glass expanded by heat.

    Holds water
    2/5
    Aeration
    4/5
    Durability
    2/5
    pH
    Neutral

    Very light and white. It lightens organic mixes, but breaks easily, floats and rises to the surface with watering.

    Use for: Cuttings and growing mixes; not in a bonsai pot.

Organic

  • Shredded bark around a flowering plant
    Photo: Geoprofi Lars / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

    Supplement

    Composted pine bark

    Shredded, composted bark of fine grade.

    Holds water
    3/5
    Aeration
    3/5
    Durability
    2/5
    pH
    Acidic

    It adds some organic matter and water retention, but breaks down within a year or two and gradually compacts the mix.

    Use for: Developing trees in growing pots, at 10–20% at most.

  • A compressed brick of coco coir
    Photo: MatiasMiika / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 3.0

    Avoid in bonsai

    Coir

    Fibre from coconut husks.

    Holds water
    5/5
    Aeration
    2/5
    Durability
    2/5
    pH
    Slightly acidic

    It holds a lot of water and compacts over time. A sustainable alternative to peat in gardening, but in a shallow pot it keeps the roots too wet.

    Use for: Seedlings and growing in the ground; not bonsai.

  • A heap of sphagnum peat moss
    Photo: Ragesoss / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 3.0

    Avoid in bonsai

    Peat and potting compost

    Decomposed plant matter from peat bogs.

    Holds water
    5/5
    Aeration
    1/5
    Durability
    1/5
    pH
    Acidic

    It is what most supermarket bonsai come in. It holds water for days, compacts and, once dry, is very hard to wet again. It is the main cause of rotten roots.

    Use for: None in bonsai: replace it at the first repotting.

Now for the mix

Each species profile gives its recommended mix. To work out how many litres of each material you need, use the calculator; to choose brand and bag size, see the buying guide.